In defense of Mr. Pernicious (Jason Fried) and Big Shoulders (Chicago)
On June 1st Jason Fried published “Never Read Another Resume” via Inc.com. It was thematically correct in the sense that Jason tends to go on irreverently about strange abstractions of reality. For me it was just another moment in his timeline. For Scott Olsen, it was the last straw. Two days ago Scott wrote a scathing rebuttal to Jason and all who follow him. Scott is a great writer and I found his views both hilarious and on-point until… he came after Chicago.
FUCK! – I AM SO TIRED OF PEOPLE SNIPING AT CHICAGO!
First, let me take care of Jason with a quick highly editorialized review of his journey. Ten(ish) years ago Jason and his colleagues, members of the elite design group 3rst (thirst), spun off a web-design company that they creatively named 37signals after the total number of signals SETI had captured that *could* represent intelligent life. They were successful as we all were because it was the very top of the internet bubble. It was raining gold those days.
Then the bubble burst.
Instead of joining a pottery club, or going back to school, or weeping at the edge of a valley that became a trailer park, Jason and his team decided to build a tool to help other design firms build closer relationships with their clients. They were successful, it’s called Basecamp. We use it, all of you should. Jason grew his self-proclaimed tiny empire out of the rubble and has since released a number of other successful products (some more than others). Jason changed his game and ours – for that and that alone, he deserves his spot in the sun. So here it is… Thank you Jason, you have made my business better and my clients happier. You are crazy, but I love you.
So why dig up Jason’s history in his defense? Because I believe you, Mr. Olson, have a Pernicious Lack of Perspective. If you know anything about Jason you should understand that he’s just a guy pointing at the moon, not giving point-by-point driving directions. He is organic, responsive, and chaotic. He is also brilliant. I fault you for taking his rants literally and also not maintaining your “west coast calm.” Jason is notorious for his ‘question everything’ approach. We share that in common but to a large extent he has found greater success in it.
Quickly, I have my share of experience with San Francisco and Silicon Valley. I love them both, they are entirely different. I’ve spent quite a bit of time in Silicon Valley, in offices with “recycled” furniture for office equipment. I’ve sat across from Jeff Hawkins (his space was nicer) sharing ideas on the future of intelligent computing. Sure, I’ve occasionally referred to SV as “The Land of Unicorns and Rainbows,” but it has always been with love. Who doesn’t love unicorns? It makes perfect sense that San Franciscans are very eager to annex SV, it’s a magical place.
So why am I based in Chicago? Very simple… Family. I was raised in Battle Creek Michigan and my wife grew up in Milwaukee. We are northerners. I don’t find solace in subtle seasonal shifts. I like change. I like leaves that drop and cold that bites, and snow that… well whatever snow does.. you get it.
I also love the people. Nobody hunkers down and get’s it done like Chicagoans. Sure we have a temper (you’re getting that, right?) and sure some of us have a funny accent, but we love what we do and we *are* “The City of Big Shoulders.”
Here’s a short list of comparisons of the two cities:
- Chicago has as very active film history, San Francisco… less so (some classics tho).
- San Francisco makes blue jeans, Chicago makes rocket ships.
- Sure you could poke us because you founded the world’s most popular web browser but we were there first and we’re coming to get you. Also yours wouldn’t still be around without a bunch of cash from a certain Menlo Park company. You could point at this but then we’d have to poke at that. Actually we’ll call this one a tie.
- For traveler’s we are the center of the universe, you are not. (Mad props to LAX tho.)
- Chicago is home to 17 Fortune 500 companies, San Francisco is home to 10.
- Chicago Innovators are awesome, umm… I couldn’t find a community award site for San Francisco… Sorry.
- You have an IDEO office, we have one too. Another tie.
- We feed the world, you import it.
Here is some more interesting comparative information from a technology company not founded in San Francisco. I’ve got work to do so I have to cut this short (lol) but wanted to give props to EveryBlock for their recent acquisition, Threadless for remaining oh-so-cool, McDonalds for making me fat, Tanagram (go us! – plug!), 37Signals, and the rest of us that don’t work for the park district (well… them too).
Shameless plug for the Chicago Poster Biennial!
9 Million of us are watching you Mr Olson. You betcha!
Posted by Joseph Juhnke on June 25, 2010

10 Comments on In defense of Mr. Pernicious (Jason Fried) and Big Shoulders (Chicago)
By Jameson Sheppard on June 25, 2010 at 3:52 pm
This had to be the most brilliant reading experience of the month!
First, I read Jason’s post, great! And since the concept was unveiled in Rework, I’ve been a huge fan of the idea.
Second, some guy who has been blogging for less than a month (?) posts the most audacious and downright ridiculous accusations (not to mention he uses the word cohort about 100 times over – how intellectual!)
And this tops it all off! I love Chicago! Have never been to SF, but I’ve worked with companies from the SV and had better experiences.
It seems Mr. Olson is very much struggling with the changing tides.
By alex on June 25, 2010 at 4:40 pm
dude, your yellow background is kinda not nice to people’s eyes.
otherwise fun post
By Kristian Andersen on June 25, 2010 at 7:51 pm
Seriously. Jason is a provocateur. I like him – don’t always (usually) agree with him – but always consider his perspective. Olsen needs to take Jason’s comments w/ a grain of salt and realize that often he makes crass generalizations to make a point. The point is the point. Pointing at the moon and all that jazz. Forgive the gratuitous use of the word “point”.
Seriously though… the yellow is a bit much.
By Joseph Juhnke on June 25, 2010 at 10:12 pm
Jameson, Alex, Kristian, thanks for your great responses. I’ve loved this city and called it home for 16 years. It means a lot to me that others care too. This post stole it’s theme from a post I made in 2007 when we still had a chance at hosting the Olympics. Sigh…
http://spill.tanagram.com/2007/03/28/the-city-that-works/
On the topic of the color (thanks again), this site was designed by the brilliant Mike Bingaman ( http://www.linkedin.com/in/mikebingaman ) in early 2007. His vision was to portray it as the irreverent spawn of our creative ranting. He wanted it to be “a look you wouldn’t forget.” I agree with you that it’s time to make the content a little easier on the eyes. We’ll work up a reinterpretation of Mike’s vision that isn’t as hard (punk rock) on your peepers.
Cheers!
J
By Youssef Sarhan on June 26, 2010 at 4:08 pm
I think I just had one of those internet moment, you know when you read something then ask yourself why you read it. Like Alex said, the yellow background is incredibly harsh on the eyes. Keep up the good work!
By John Fan on June 26, 2010 at 6:50 pm
Google is based in Mountain View, not Menlo Park.
By Brian Johnson on June 26, 2010 at 6:59 pm
Article is filled with inaccuracies. Everyblock was not a successful exit for it’s investors, Chicago is urban sprawl with cheaper labor, thus more labor based companies, 80%+ of successful VC exits return the Bay Area.
What are the stats between SV vs Chicago in terms of successful tech startups ($100+m in revenue a year)?
By Walter Smith on June 26, 2010 at 8:37 pm
Nothing against Chicago, love the place, but I can’t let the statement that you “make rocket ships” pass. As far as I know, Boeing makes nothing but paperwork in Chicago. (I’m from Seattle, one of the places Boeing makes actual stuff–though still, no rocket ships.)
By Joseph Juhnke on June 27, 2010 at 1:22 pm
Youssef, thank you for your kind post!
John, You are correct, thank you. I was referring to the place it was born. See here: http://www.usatoday.com/tech/techinvestor/corporatenews/2007-07-04-google-wojcicki_N.htm
Brian, thanks for your post. Please share the inaccuracies with me. Also, please don’t think I don’t give major props for SF. This post isn’t an attack on SF, its a rebuttal defending Chicago. You see, I believe the world does not see us for the great city we are.
If you know the history of Everyblock, I’m not sure why you say it wasn’t a successful exit? Can you share?
Your statement that we are “cheap labor” like offshoring is offensive. I hope you don’t really believe that. It’s Midwestern academia that provides a large percentage of the ideas that end up growing out of “the bay area.” Larry Page was a graduate from U of M. Ray Ozzie grew up in Chicago. I can go on. My question to you is why do you need to put us down?
Walter, I’m extra sensitive to your point (thank you!) because I know Boeing moving headquarters from Seattle was a big loss for your fine city. Too your point I would argue, although I have not researched it, that no blue jeans are actually made in SF either. I do work with the Boeing guys from time to time (in Seattle) and can assure you that everything they make deserves the title “rocket-ship.” I can’t really talk about whether any of it travels to space though.
Cheers!
By Tim Chapel on June 28, 2010 at 4:51 pm
Joe, i think you missed Fermilab and Argonne. As i understand some work goes on there that is moderately inspiring
Write a Comment on In defense of Mr. Pernicious (Jason Fried) and Big Shoulders (Chicago)
Comments on In defense of Mr. Pernicious (Jason Fried) and Big Shoulders (Chicago) are now closed.